In my private women’s group on
Facebook, someone posted about how proud they were that the younger
generation of women are no longer tolerating the things that used to
be considered normal. They are not tolerating violence, neglect,
uselessness, or the lack of connection. It is genuinely wonderful to
see. But in the comments, many women my age and older began blaming
themselves for staying in bad situations as long as they did.
Since seeing that thread, I have
thought a lot about the conversation. Not just about the original
post, but about the comments from women asking themselves why they
allowed certain things, why they stayed, and why they did not leave
earlier. The truth is that leaving damage is incredibly difficult
because most of us have a strong sense of hope and faith in people’s
ability to change. And when it comes to men, the bar for what needs
to change has historically been very low.
This is not a flaw in who we are. It
is a flaw built into the system. It is the culture we were raised in,
the examples we were given, and the messages sent to us both out loud
and silently. Many of us are mothers and grandmothers who actively
tell younger women not to repeat the patterns we lived through. We
explain why. We talk about the actual damage done. But how many of us
had mothers who did that for us. Some. How many had grandmothers who
did that. Again, some, but not many.
In my own situation, my mother was
essentially a cautionary tale. She moved from one disastrous
relationship to another with such consistency that it almost became
impressive. It takes effort to find men who do not just slip below
the bar of tolerable but sink so far beneath it that they are
practically buried in the dirt. I do not blame her for this. I know
her history and the abuse she suffered. From my own experiences with
mental illness, I understand hers. I know why she self soothed
with substances and why she believed she was not worthy of decent
partners. I know why she thought that if she could prove she was
worth changing for, even to a terrible partner, then maybe she was
worthy of love at all.
I have studied pictures of her at
nineteen and realized that this is where I began. In this broken,
damaged child. Understanding that does not erase or excuse the pain
her children suffered, but it does allow me to heal through the
situation.
My mother was part of a cycle. A cycle
of untreated mental illness passed down through generations. A cycle
of manipulation. Her father was, by all accounts, considered a good
man. And in many ways he was. He met the basic bar for men and even
went beyond it. He worked a steady job, provided for his family, was
calm, did not drink or use drugs, and although he smoked, that was
not considered an issue at the time. He was soft spoken, steady,
and did not create a home full of nervous energy. He was a good
Christian, a deacon of his church, helpful, humble, kind, caring, and
would never have considered raising a violent hand to anyone. All of
these things were true. None of it was fake.
But people are complicated, and
another truth existed alongside all of that. He valued his birth
family more than the family he created. He bought his parents a home
before he built his own. When he finally built his own home, he
placed it within a two minute walk of his parents so he could be
there at any time. He paid their bills. As advancements happened, his
parents received them first. They had indoor plumbing and electricity
before his wife and children did. Only when he had additional funds
did his own household receive those things. It is strange to think
about now, but in rural areas during the 1950s and 60s, this was
still common.
He bought cars for his parents and his
sister whenever they needed one. Always. Without fail. And while that
may still sound generous, it came at a cost. His wife and children
were always last on the list, and it was not only that they were
last. My grandmother had to cook for his parents, clean for them, run
their errands, and take them places. She essentially ran two
households and was not compensated for any of it.
When my uncle was eight or nine, he
was sent to work at the general store his grandfather owned. The
store was across the street, so he walked over after school and
worked until eight every night, then worked full shifts on weekends.
He was not paid. This continued for roughly eight years.
When my grandfather’s father died in
the early 1960s, his mother asked for companionship. In response, my
grandfather sent my mother to live with her. For some people, living
with a grandmother would have been ideal. I wish it could have been
that for my mother. It was not. It was servitude. My grandmother
still did most of the domestic labor in her mother in law’s
home, but my mother did the rest. Until she was around twelve, she
was not required to cook, but she had to serve meals and wash
everything afterward. She had to keep the house spotless. She once
told me that her grandmother would walk through the house several
times each evening, and if anything was out of order, my mother would
be hit.
Her grandmother was verbally and
physically violent. Often. Viciously. And my grandfather knew this.
He allowed it. He created the situation that made it possible.
So was he a good man. Yes. No. It is
true that his parents raised him to value them first, but at some
point, when you see bruises on your child’s legs, something inside
you should recognize that the situation must stop.
My point in telling this story is that
my grandmother saw the patterns. She spoke up about how wrong the
situation was. She did so often and loudly. For her efforts, she was
labeled a nagging woman. And nothing changed.
When I was born, and the abusive
grandmother died in the same year, my grandmother made decisions. She
spoke to me about how things worked. She did not simply suggest that
I choose differently. She insisted on it. I was fortunate to have
someone who told me directly that the patterns could and should be
broken. Not everyone gets that.
Modern girls walk away now. They do
not allow certain behaviors to begin in the first place. They do not
fear being alone because they understand that alone, for women, is
often another word for peaceful and quiet. They understand that alone
is misleading anyway, because people can have friends, family,
roommates, and even their own children without involving a walking
red flag in the matter.
They understand these things
because they grew up with the message, spoken and unspoken, that they
have personal value that does not depend on others. They learned that
they have the right to safety, comfort, and peace. They learned that
they are enough on their own.
You who raised the next generations
deserve credit for telling them that the cycles should be broken. You
showed them the beauty and value of independence and freedom. You
worked hard to find your own healing, footing, and sense of self. I
commend all of you for that.
TL;DR: We were shaped by the
generations before us, but we are the ones who shape the future.