So I entered a contest and ended up as one of the Honorable Mentions.
There were four overall winners for various categories, and then ten Honorable Mentions. I was pleased — there were a massive number of entries.
However, the very first thing I saw, even before noticing that I had won, was my name mentioned in a comment thread.
Curious, I opened it. And… it was someone complaining that I won my little Honorable Mention spot. Not just me — most of the winners, actually.
Here’s the deal.
The contest was for a body of work that told a story highlighting an emotion. The rules stated that you could not submit just one image; you had to submit a series that created a narrative.
You had two choices:
Option One: Submit your work as a collection. Option Two: Submit your work as a video. Video uploads were limited to 90 seconds.
Those were literally the options provided.
My interpretation was simple: I could create a single video that told one story — a story that fits within 90 seconds. To me, the point was to tell a complete narrative within that timeframe.
So that’s what I did.
What other people understood this to mean was: You could create multiple videos that together told a very long story.
And that’s what they did.
Neither approach was explicitly right or wrong. The rules didn’t forbid either method. No one on the judging panel, and no one monitoring the contest, sent out emails saying, “This isn’t what the rules meant — please change your submission.”
As a result, the people who submitted multiple videos are now complaining that those of us who submitted one video broke the rules because we only submitted one clip.
But the rules never said “not just one clip.” They said “not just one image.” There is a difference.
And while I absolutely understand their frustration — the rules should have been clearer about what was required, what wasn’t, and what might be overkill — it doesn’t change the fact that I didn’t do anything wrong.
I also empathize with the pain of submitting (in some cases) bodies of work with 100+ pieces and feeling like it was overlooked.
However:
My win is legit. My win was earned. My work was good.
I’m not going to say anything in that comment thread. I’m not going to defend my work, because I do not defend or justify what I make. I don’t believe any creator should.
I do, however, want to acknowledge how frustrating it is that a win I should have been thrilled about is now tinged by the fact that I found out about it through someone questioning its validity.