June’s Ipsy Extra lineup dropped, and as always, I approached it with equal parts excitement and dread. You know, the emotional cocktail only a subscription box can deliver. It’s the familiar ritual: scroll, squint, whisper “don’t you dare,” and pray the algorithm doesn’t decide I need yet another mascara.
This month’s offerings are actually… good. Suspiciously good. Good enough that I’m already bracing for the two YOU HAVE NO CHOICE, YOU WILL TAKE THIS items Ipsy loves to assign like a chaotic fairy godmother.
But before we get to the predictions, here’s the lineup:
• Dew of the Gods Maui Glaze Oil Cleanser
• Moonslice Beauty eyeshadow & pigment palette
• Pinky B Beauty Hot Commodity bronzer palette
• Tower 28 ShineOn Lip Jelly
• Tower 28 LipSoftie tinted balm
• Lucky Chick eye brush trio
• Tarte Lights Camera Lashes Platinum
• Dieux Air Angel Gel Cream
• Rare Beauty Stay Vulnerable Melting Blush
A surprisingly solid mix of skincare, lips, and the usual “we found this in the warehouse” suspects.
My Ranking: The Joy-to-Utility Index
1. Dieux Air Angel Gel Cream
If Ipsy wants to force something on me, let it be this. Please, beauty gods, please.
It’s lightweight, elegant, and the kind of moisturizer that quietly earns its keep. I have plenty of skincare right now, but this is the kind of “future me will be smug” product I never regret.
2. Tower 28 ShineOn Lip Jelly
A no-brainer. A must-have. A “yes, I will take another” moment. I'm a little obsessed with Tower 28 anyway because they're supposed to be really good for people with sensitive skin. Mostly I've been eyeing their skin products, but Tower 28 lip products are joy in a tube, and this one was already on my mental wishlist.
3. Rare Beauty Melting Blush
Do I have a lot of blush? Yes.
Do I still want this? Also yes.
It’s soft, melty, and natural — the kind of blush that makes you look like you’re lit from within by a gentle secret.
4. Tower 28 LipSoftie Balm
I probably won’t be allowed both Tower 28 items, but if the stars align, this is the one I’ll snag. Getting both would be the score of the month, really. Even if I end up with brushes and mascara because I have no choice.
5. Moonslice Palette
Pretty, fun, and absolutely unnecessary for someone who already has more palettes than eyelids.
6. Tarte Lights Camera Lashes Platinum
NO.
No more mascara.
No more tubes.
No more “but this one is platinum.”
I refuse to build a mascara mausoleum in my drawer.
7. Dew of the Gods Oil Cleanser
Cute name, cute vibe, mid performance.
I don’t need novelty skincare right now.
8. Lucky Chick Brush Trio
Ipsy has been brush-happy lately, and
I’m fully stocked.
And while the brush they sent out with
Ultimate last month was really great and I love my Iconic London
brushes they sent out a few months ago, yeah no. No more brushes.
These aren’t special enough to break the streak.
9. Pinky B Bronzer Palette
I have a soft spot for her — I follow her on Instagram and I’m genuinely thrilled she made it into Ipsy Extras.
But I do not need more bronzer.
This is a “support from afar” moment.
The Forced-Choice Fear: What Ipsy Might Do
Every month, Ipsy assigns two items you cannot decline — the Dreaded Duo of Doom.
Worst-case scenario?
They saddle me with:
• the mascara
• the brushes
The Twin Horsemen of the Forced Choice Apocalypse.
But realistically, June’s lineup is too strong for them to waste both forced slots on pure filler. When they have Rare Beauty, Tower 28, Dieux, and a palette in the mix, they usually anchor at least one forced item with something mid-tier but respectable.
Most likely forced combos:
• Moonslice palette + Dieux which I will live with with a contented heart.
• Moonslice palette + Lucky Chick brushes Please no.
• Dieux + Lucky Chick brushes Sigh. Fiiiiine. At least I'd still get the one I want.
Least likely:
• Mascara + brushes Pleasenopleasenopleasenopleaseno.
• Mascara + anything, honestly
Mascara is too polarizing. Too many people have it marked “rarely.” Ipsy knows better than to start a riot.
The Best Possible Outcome
If Dieux is one of my forced items, I’m fine with that.
It’s the only product on the list where a forced slot feels like a gentle nudge instead of a punishment.
If Dieux is locked in, my choice slots become pure joy:
• Tower 28 ShineOn
• Rare Beauty Melting Blush
• maybe LipSoftie if the universe is kind
That’s a perfect June.
Final Prediction
June is shaping up to be one of those rare Ipsy Extra months where the math actually works out. Even if the algorithm wakes up and chooses mild violence (which is mascara, another mascara is violence), I’m still walking away with at least two items I genuinely want.
But if they force that mascara on me?
Just know I’ll be here, icing my foot from the Selena Gomez jar incident, muttering at the universe, and adding yet another tube to the Mascara Drawer of Shame.