Tuesday, January 25, 2022

It Could Happen

People are freaking out that the Amazon show possibly maybe has one of Galadriel's brothers alive and leading the orcs. People keep screaming that this isn't canon...the thing is, it COULD be.  This is how it works.

No one sees Aegnor's body after Dagor Bragolloch. There are reports that he's dead, but no one can confirm.

Aegnor said he was going to wait for his mortal love and never leave Mandos to be re-embodied. No one in Mandos may have known about this and all of his family is just going to assume he stays there. Again, no real confirmation of where he is. He could have been captured.

Sauron has a nasty habit of using people's loved ones against them. He could have figured out that this elf lord was in love with a mortal woman and captured Andreth's soul before it could leave for wherever mortals go.

Aegnor loved her completely. If Sauron had him captured and showed him that he could torture Andreth's soul if he didn't obey, I bet Aegnor would have done what Sauron wanted.

So he wouldn't be EVIL exactly, but certainly on the villain side and capable of causing a lot of problems.

No comments:

Post a Comment